Air Fryer Peanut Butter Cookies
Air Fryer peanut butter cookies are crisp at the edges, soft in the middle and full of chocolate pieces. They have a pronounced nutty flavour, a slightly caramel-like sweetness from the brown sugar and that lovely moment when the chocolate is still gently soft after baking.
The Air Fryer works particularly well for these cookies when it has a larger chamber and top and bottom heating elements. The top element browns the top, while the bottom helps bake the base, so there is no need to turn the cookies halfway through cooking. That is a big advantage for baking, because soft cookies are easy to damage before they have set.
The most common problem with Air Fryer cookies is a top that is too browned and a centre that is underbaked, or a pale, soft base. In this recipe, the most important things are the portion size, the spacing on the shelf and a short rest after baking, because the cookies continue to bake for a few minutes outside the appliance.
This recipe is ideal when you want to bake a larger batch of sweet treats without switching on the oven. With the Llivekit 30 l, 1800 W air fryer, with top and bottom heating elements, around 16 cookies from a portion scooped with a 60 ml ice cream scoop will fit on one shelf.
Air Fryer Peanut Butter Cookies
28
servings15
minutes15
minutes175
kcalIngredients
2 cups plain flour, 240 g
1 tsp bicarbonate of soda
1/2 tsp salt
1/2 cup soft butter, 113 g
1/2 cup peanut butter, 125 g
1 cup brown cane sugar, 220 g
1/2 cup white sugar, 100 g
1 tsp vanilla extract
2 large eggs
1 cup chocolate pieces or chocolate chips, 175 g
Directions
- Preheat the Air Fryer to 180°C. With a large model with top and bottom heating elements, a few minutes is enough for the chamber to heat evenly.
- Fill a medium bowl with the flour, bicarbonate of soda and salt, then mix the dry ingredients with a whisk. This helps the bicarbonate of soda distribute evenly and the cookies will not have bitter spots.
- Add the soft butter, peanut butter, brown sugar and white sugar to a large bowl. Beat until the mixture becomes lighter, fluffier and slightly creamy.
- Add the eggs one at a time, mixing after each addition. The mixture may look less smooth for a moment, but after adding the flour it will return to the right consistency.
- Add the vanilla extract and mix briefly. Vanilla enhances the flavour of the peanut butter and chocolate, but should not dominate.
- Add the dry ingredients to the butter mixture in 2–3 batches. Mix only until combined, because overworking the flour can make the cookies tougher.
- Add the chocolate pieces and mix with a spatula. The dough should be thick, soft and easy to scoop.
- Prepare a shelf or tray that fits the Air Fryer. Line it with baking parchment cut to the size of the shelf, but do not block the entire airflow if your appliance does not like that.
- Scoop portions of the dough with a 60 ml ice cream scoop. Arrange the balls with gaps between them, because they will spread sideways during cooking.
- Bake the cookies at 180°C for 12–15 minutes. With the Llivekit 30 l model with a cookies programme, 180°C and 15 minutes works well for portions scooped with a 60 ml scoop.
- Do not turn the cookies if you are baking them in an appliance with top and bottom heating elements. The bottom element helps bake the base, and turning could damage the soft cookies.
- Check for doneness by the colour of the edges. The edges should be lightly golden, the centre still gently soft, and the base baked through but not dark.
- If the cookies are browned on top but seem too soft in the middle, leave them on the shelf for another 3–5 minutes after switching off the appliance. The residual heat will help them set without drying them out.
- Move the cookies to a wire rack only after about 5 minutes. While hot, they are very delicate, and after a short rest they hold their shape more easily.
A few words about the ingredients
The butter should be soft but not melted. Butter that is too warm will make the dough spread faster, and the cookies may turn out flat and greasy. Soft butter whips easily with sugar, which makes the mixture lighter.
The peanut butter can be smooth or crunchy. Smooth gives a more even texture, while crunchy adds small pieces of nuts. A fairly thick peanut butter works best, without a very large amount of separated oil.
Brown sugar gives the cookies a slightly caramel-like flavour and a softer middle. White sugar helps create lightly crisp edges. It is worth keeping both types, because together they give a better structure than white sugar alone.
You can choose the chocolate to suit your taste. Milk chocolate will give a sweeter result, while dark chocolate cuts through the sweetness of the dough and pairs better with the intense peanut butter flavour.
My tip after making them
For cookies scooped with a 60 ml scoop, the best result comes from baking them on a shelf with clear gaps between them. In a large air fryer with two heating elements, the base bakes evenly, so there is no need to turn the cookies, which is a real advantage with soft dough.
The 180°C cookies programme and 15 minutes in this particular type of appliance works well for larger cookies. For smaller portions, it is worth checking from 10–12 minutes.
Why do peanut butter cookies in the Air Fryer turn out differently from oven-baked ones?
The Air Fryer works more intensely than a conventional oven because hot air circulates quickly around the food. For cookies, that means the surface sets faster, the edges brown more strongly and the baking time is shorter.
Butter, sugar and peanut butter react very quickly at a high temperature. The edges of the cookies begin to brown and the sugar caramelises slightly. That is why the cookies can have a crisp rim even though the centre stays soft.
In a large appliance with top and bottom heating elements, the heat acts more evenly on both sides of the cookies. This is an important difference compared with many basket-style Air Fryers, where the base can be paler and softer.
When baking cookies, it is better not to raise the temperature too much. A temperature that is too high will brown the top quickly, but the centre will not have time to bake through. For large cookies, 180°C is a safe starting point, and the time is adjusted to the portion size.
What temperature and time should you use for peanut butter cookies in the Air Fryer?
The base temperature for these cookies is 180°C. For portions scooped with a 60 ml ice cream scoop, the time is usually 12–15 minutes. In a large Llivekit 30 l appliance with top and bottom heating elements, the cookies programme at 180°C and 15 minutes gives well-baked, larger cookies.
Smaller cookies bake faster, so it is worth reducing the time to 9–11 minutes. Very large, tall portions may need the full 15 minutes and a few minutes resting after baking.
With more powerful appliances, check the colour earlier. With weaker models, the time may need to be extended by 2–3 minutes, but it is better to add time gradually rather than baking for too long straight away.
| Variation | Temperature | Time | Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Small cookies | 170–180°C | 8–11 minutes | check when the edges start to turn golden |
| Cookies from a 60 ml scoop | 180°C | 12–15 minutes | the centre may be soft straight after baking |
| Very large cookies | 170°C | 15–18 minutes | the lower temperature helps bake the centre through |
| Powerful Air Fryer | 170–180°C | 1–3 minutes less | check the colour after 10 minutes |
| Weaker Air Fryer | 180°C | 2–3 minutes more | bake through briefly, in batches |
Why don’t Air Fryer peanut butter cookies turn out perfectly?
The cookies are too flat.
The most common cause is butter that is too soft or melted. The mixture should be creamy, not runny. If the dough seems very soft, chill it for 20–30 minutes before baking.
The base is pale and soft.
This may happen more often in an appliance without a bottom heating element. Baking on a well-heated tray or rack lined with baking parchment helps. In a model with a bottom heating element, the base bakes better and you usually do not need to turn the cookies.
The cookies are too dry.
They were probably baked for too long or were too small for the set time. Take them out when the edges are golden and the centre is still slightly soft. After a few minutes they will firm up.
The cookies are merging together.
Too little spacing on the shelf is a common problem. The dough balls need room because the heat loosens the structure of the butter and sugar. For larger batches, it is better to bake in two rounds than to crowd everything on one shelf.
The top browns too quickly.
The temperature may be too high for your appliance. Bake the next batch at 170°C and extend the time by 2–3 minutes. This is especially helpful for larger cookies.
The chocolate burns on top.
If you use small chips or chopped chocolate, mix some into the dough and add only a few larger pieces on top. Dark chocolate usually withstands baking better than very sweet milk chocolate.
How do you get crispier edges?
Crispy edges depend on three things: the right amount of sugar, enough spacing and not overbaking the whole batch. The edges should brown, but the centre should not dry out.
It also helps to bake without too thick a layer of parchment and without a silicone mat, which can limit heat from underneath. If you use parchment, press it down with the dough portions so it does not lift in the airflow.
For a crisper result, you can leave the cookies on the rack until completely cool. Warm chocolate and a soft centre are lovely straight after baking, but the full structure only appears once they have cooled.
Can the dough be made ahead?
You can make the cookie dough ahead and keep it in the fridge. The easiest way is to shape the balls straight away, place them in a container and separate the layers with baking parchment.
Chilled dough will bake a little more slowly and may spread less. Add 1–2 minutes of baking time, or leave the balls on the worktop for 10 minutes before putting them into the Air Fryer.
This is a good option when you want to bake only some of the cookies straight away and keep the rest for the next day.
How do you store peanut butter cookies?
Store the cooled cookies in an airtight container at room temperature for 3–5 days. They have the best texture once completely cool, when the edges are slightly crisp and the middle stays soft.
Do not put warm cookies into a box. Steam will be trapped inside and the cookies will soften. If you want a crisper result, wait until they are completely cool on a wire rack.
How do you reheat the cookies so the chocolate is soft again?
You can reheat the cookies in the Air Fryer at 150–160°C for 2–3 minutes. That is enough for the chocolate to soften slightly and for the edges to regain a pleasant texture.
Do not heat them for too long, or they will become dry. For larger cookies, it is better to set a lower temperature and a shorter time, then add a minute if needed.
Can you freeze the cookies or the raw dough?
It is best to freeze the raw dough balls. Shape the portions, freeze them flat first, then transfer them to a bag or container. That way you can bake only as many cookies as you need.
Bake the frozen balls from frozen, usually adding 2–4 minutes to the baking time. Similar guidance applies to Air Fryer cookie recipes where frozen portions need a few more minutes than fresh dough.
Baked cookies can also be frozen, but after thawing they will be a little softer. It is best to refresh them briefly in the Air Fryer.
How can you change the flavour of the cookies?
You can add a pinch of cinnamon if you want a warmer, more autumnal flavour. It goes well with peanut butter and brown sugar.
Some of the chocolate can be replaced with chopped peanuts. The cookies will be more crunchy and less sweet.
For a more dessert-like version, add a little coarse sea salt on top straight after baking. Salt brings out the flavour of the chocolate and peanut butter.
FAQ
How many minutes should you bake peanut butter cookies in the Air Fryer?
Cookies made from portions scooped with a 60 ml ice cream scoop should be baked for about 12–15 minutes at 180°C. In a large appliance with top and bottom heating elements, 15 minutes gives a well-baked base and lightly golden edges. Check smaller cookies after 9–10 minutes. After taking them out, leave them on the shelf for a few minutes, because they are very soft when hot.
Do you need to turn cookies in the Air Fryer?
With an appliance with top and bottom heating elements, you do not need to turn the cookies. The base bakes from underneath and the top browns from above. Turning could damage the cookies, because they are delicate while baking. With models without a bottom heating element, it is better to use a heated tray or rack than to move soft cookies halfway through.
Can baking parchment be used?
Yes, baking parchment is handy, especially with soft dough containing butter and chocolate. However, it needs to be cut to fit the shelf or tray and should not completely block the airflow. It is best to weigh the parchment down with the dough portions so it does not lift in the draught. Do not put parchment on its own into an empty, preheated Air Fryer.
Why are the cookies too soft?
The cookies may be too soft if they were baked for too short a time, if the portions were too large, or if they were taken off the shelf straight away. Hot peanut butter cookies are delicate and only set after a few minutes. If the edges are pale, bake them for another 2–3 minutes. If the edges are golden, leave them to rest rather than extending the baking time.
How do you tell if the cookies are done?
Done cookies have lightly golden edges, a slightly matte top and a soft centre. They should not be completely hard when taken out, because they may turn out dry once cooled. The base should be baked and lightly browned. For the first batch, it is worth checking one cookie underneath after 5 minutes resting.
Can these cookies be made without peanut butter?
You can, but then it will be a different type of cookie. Peanut butter affects not only the flavour, but also the richness and texture of the dough. If you leave it out, the mixture may be too dry or less cohesive. A better swap would be another thick nut butter, such as almond or cashew butter.
Does the dough need chilling before baking?
Not if the mixture is thick and holds its shape well. Chilling helps if the butter was very soft or the kitchen is warm. 20–30 minutes in the fridge is enough. Chilled dough spreads less during baking, but may need 1–2 minutes more.
Air Fryer peanut butter cookies are best when baked at 180°C, with gaps between the portions and without taking them off the shelf straight after baking. The key moment is when to remove them: the edges should be golden and the centre still slightly soft.
You can vary the flavour with different chocolate, added peanuts or a little salt on top. The baking time can vary depending on the power, chamber size, heating elements and cookie size, so the first batch is worth using as the best test for your Air Fryer.